魏书十六 · 杜畿子恕传 · 附孟康、乐详
恕字务伯,太和中为散骑黄门侍郎。恕推诚以质,不治饰,少无名誉。及在朝,不结交援,专心向公。每政有得失,常引纲维以正言,于是侍中辛毗等器重之。时公卿以下大议损益,恕以为「古之刺史,奉宣六条,以清静为名,威风著称,今可勿令领兵,以专民事。」俄而镇北将军吕昭又领兾州,乃上疏曰:
杜恕,字务伯,太和年间任散骑黄门侍郎。他为人真诚质朴,不事修饰,年少时没有名声。到了在朝任职时,他不结交攀附,一心为公。每当朝政有得失时,他常常援引纲纪法度来发表正直的言论,因此侍中辛毗等人很器重他。当时公卿以下官员广泛议论制度的增减变革,杜恕认为:“古代的刺史,遵奉并宣示六条,以清静为声誉,以威严著称。现在可以不让他们领兵,以便专心治理民政。”不久镇北将军吕昭又兼管冀州,杜恕于是上疏说:
Du Shu, courtesy name Wubo, served during the Taihe era as a Cavalier Attendant Gentleman and Attendant Gentleman within the Yellow Gates. Sincere and straightforward, he did not put on appearances, and in his youth had no reputation. When at court, Du Shu cultivated no private connections, but devoted himself wholly to the public good. Whenever discussing the merits and faults of government policy, he appealed to the principles of the state and spoke forthrightly to set matters right. Palace Attendant Xin Pi and others therefore held him in high regard. At the time, the excellencies and ministers below them held a wide-ranging debate on administrative reforms. Du Shu argued: "The Inspectors of old proclaimed and enforced the Six Articles. They were renowned for governing with restraint and tranquillity and for the authority they commanded. Inspectors today should not be permitted to command troops, so that they may devote themselves to only civil affairs." Soon afterwards, Lü Zhao, General Who Garrisons the North, was also concurrently given charge of Ji Province. Du Shu thereupon submitted a memorial:
《杜氏新书》曰:恕少与冯翊李丰俱为父任,緫角相善。及各成人,丰砥砺名行以要世誉,而恕诞节直意,与丰殊趣。丰竟驰名一时,京师之士多为之游说。而当路者或以丰名过其实,而恕被褐怀玉也。由此为丰所不善。恕亦任其自然,不力行以合时。丰以显仕朝廷,恕犹居家自若。明帝以恕大臣子,擢拜散骑侍郎,数月,转补黄门侍郎。
The Du Shi Xinshu / New Book of Du Clan states: In their youth, Du Shu and Li Feng of Pingyi both received appointments on account of their fathers, and had been close since childhood. As they reached adulthood, Li Feng assiduously cultivated his reputation and conduct to win public acclaim, whereas Du Shu was unrestrained in manner and forthright in his actions. Their aspirations thus diverged sharply. Li Feng ultimately did win fame in his day, and many gentlemen in the capital praised and recommended him. Yet some among those in power considered Li Feng's fame greater than his substance, while Du Shu wore coarse cloth but harboured jade within. Li Feng therefore regarded him with hostility. Du Shu continued to follow his own nature and made no effort to conform to the times. When Li Feng rose to prominent positions at court, Du Shu was still at home without office, unperturbed. Cao Rui (posthumously honoured as Emperor Ming, the Radiant Emperor), considering Du Shu the son of a great minister, promoted him and appointed him Cavalier Attendant Gentleman. Several months later, he was transferred to the post of Attendant Gentleman within the Yellow Gates.
The Shiyu / Accounts of this Generation states: Lü Zhao, courtesy name Zizhan, was from Dongping State. His eldest son, Lü Xun, courtesy name Changti, served as a staff of the Chancellor of State and enjoyed the favour of Sima Zhao (posthumously honoured as King Wen, the Civil King). His second son, Lü An, courtesy name Zhongti, was a close friend of Ji Kang and was executed with him. Another son, Lü Cui, courtesy name Jiti, served as Intendant of Henan. Lü Cui's son Lü Yu, courtesy name Jingyu, served as Deputy Imperial Censor.
「帝王之道,莫尚乎安民;安民之术,在于丰财。丰财者,务本而节用也。方今二贼未灭。戎车亟驾,此自熊虎之士展力之秋也。然搢绅之儒,横加荣慕,搤腕抗论,以孙、吴为首,州郡牧守,咸共忽恤民之术,修将率之事。农桑之民,竞干戈之业,不可谓务本。帑藏岁虚而制度岁广,民力岁衰而赋役岁兴,不可谓节用。
帝王治理天下的道理,没有比安定百姓更重要的;安定百姓的办法,在于使财富丰足。使财富丰足,在于以农为本、节省用度。如今吴、蜀二贼尚未消灭,战车频繁出动,这正是熊虎一般的勇士施展勇力的时候。然而士大夫们却毫无道理地追慕荣耀,扼腕高谈阔论,把孙武、吴起奉为第一等人物;州牧、郡守全都忽视抚恤百姓的办法,而去讲习将帅统兵之事。种田养蚕的百姓争着从事战争之事,不能说是以农为本。国库一年比一年空虚,制度却一年比一年繁多;民力一年比一年衰弱,赋税徭役却一年比一年增多,不能说是节省用度。
"The Way of emperors and kings holds nothing higher than bringing peace to the people. The means of doing so lie in increasing wealth, and wealth is increased by strengthening foundations and curbing expenditure. At present, the two rebels have yet to be destroyed, and the war chariots are repeatedly put in motion. This is indeed the time for warriors fierce as bears and tigers to exert their strength. Yet even our robed scholars rashly aspire to martial glory, clasping their wrists and declaiming, with Sun Wu and Wu Qi as their foremost models. Governors and Grand Administrators throughout the provinces and commanderies neglect the art of caring for the people and apply themselves instead to the business of generals. Those who should till the fields and tend silkworms turn instead to the pursuit of arms. This cannot be called fostering the foundations of livelihood. The treasury is depleted year by year while official establishments continue to expand; the people's strength declines year by year while taxes and corvée multiply. This cannot be called curbing expenditure.
今大魏奄有十州之地,而承丧乱之弊,计其户口不如往昔一州之民,然而二方僭逆,北虏未賔,三边遘难,绕天略帀;所以统一州之民,经营九州之地,其为艰难,譬策羸马以取道里,岂可不加意爱惜其力哉?以武皇帝之节俭,府藏充实,犹不能十州拥兵;郡且二十也。今荆、扬、青、徐、幽、并、雍、凉缘边诸州皆有兵矣,其所恃内充府库外制四夷者,惟兖、豫、司、兾而已。
如今大魏拥有十州的土地,却承接了丧乱之后的凋敝,统计户口还不如过去一州的民户多。然而两方僭越叛逆,北方胡人尚未归顺,三面边境都遭受祸难,几乎把天下环绕了一周。因此,要用相当于过去一州的民力去经营九州的土地,这种艰难就好比鞭策瘦弱的马去赶远路,怎么能不格外爱惜它的力气呢!即使凭武皇帝的节俭和府藏的充实,尚且不能让十州和将近二十个郡都拥有军队。如今荆、扬、青、徐、幽、并、雍、凉这些沿边各州都已经有了军队,而所依靠来对内充实府库、对外制服四夷的,只有兖、豫、司、冀四州罢了。
The Great Wei now holds the lands of ten provinces, yet has inherited the ravages of war and disorder. Its population, by calculation, is smaller than that of a single province in former times. But usurpers remain in two quarters, the northern tribes have not submitted, and three frontiers are beset by troubles; danger presses upon the realm from almost every side. Thus, in reality, we have the people of but one province, yet must administer the lands of nine. The difficulty is like driving a weary horse over a long road. How could we not carefully husband its remaining strength? Even with Cao Cao's (posthumously honoured as Emperor Wu, the Martial Emperor) frugality and full treasuries, the state could not sustain troops across ten provinces when it possessed only twenty commanderies. Now the frontier provinces of Jing Province, Yang Province, Qing Province, Xu Province, You Province, Bing Province, Yong Province, and Liang Province all maintain armies. Only Yan Province, Yu Province, Si Province, and Ji Province remain to supply the treasuries within and hold the peoples beyond the frontiers in check.
臣前以州郡典兵,则专心军功,不勤民事,宜别置将守,以尽治理之务;而陛下复以兾州宠秩吕昭。兾州户口最多,田多垦辟,又有桑枣之饶,国家征求之府,诚不当复任以兵事也。若以北方当须镇守,自可专置大将以镇安之。计所置吏士之费,与兼官无异。然昭于人才尚复易;中朝苟乏人,兼才者势不独多。以此推之,知国家以人择官,不为官择人也。官得其人,则政平讼理;政平故民富实,讼理故囹圄空虚。
我先前认为:州、郡的长官如果掌管军队,就会专心建立军功,不尽力于民政;应当另设将领和守令,以便尽到治理的职责。陛下却又用冀州来尊宠并任命吕昭。冀州户口最多,田地大多已经开垦,又有桑树、枣树的富饶,是国家征收财物的府库,实在不该再让它承担军事事务。如果认为北方必须镇守,自然可以专门设置大将去镇守安抚它。计算为此设置的官吏和士兵的费用,与兼任官职没有差别。然而,以人才而论,吕昭仍算是容易找到的;朝廷如果缺少人才,兼有文武才能的人势必不会特别多。由此推断,可知国家是在因人设置官职,而不是为官职挑选人。官职得到合适的人选,政事就会平和,诉讼也会得到审理;政事平和,所以百姓富足充实;诉讼得到审理,所以监狱空虚。
I, your servant, previously believed that when provincial and commandery officials command troops, they devote themselves to military achievements and neglect civil affairs. Generals and governors should therefore be appointed separately, so that civil affairs may be properly administered. Yet Your Majesty has again honoured Lü Zhao with appointment over Ji Province. Ji Province has the largest population, much cultivated land, and an abundance of mulberries and jujubes. It is the chief source of the state's levies and should certainly not also be burdened with military affairs. It is the chief source of the state's levies and should certainly not also be burdened with military affairs. If the north requires defence, a senior general may be appointed specifically to secure it. The cost of the necessary officers and troops would be no greater than if the civil and military offices remained combined. Even considering Lu Zhao alone, a man of his abilities could readily be replaced. Can the court truly be so lacking in men that those capable in both civil and military affairs are so few? From this, it appears that the state tailors offices to men, rather than selecting men to suit the offices. When the right man holds office, government is equitable and lawsuits are justly settled. Equitable government enriches the people; justly settled lawsuits leave the prisons empty.
陛下践阼,天下断狱百数十人,岁岁增多,至五百余人矣。民不益多,法不益峻。以此推之,非政教陵迟,牧守不称之明效欤?往年牛死,通率天下十能损二;麦不半收,秋种未下。若二贼游魂于疆埸,飞刍挽粟,千里不及。究此之术,岂在彊兵乎?武士劲卒愈多,愈多愈病耳。夫天下犹人之体,腹心充实,四支虽病,终无大患;今兖、豫、司、兾亦天下之腹心也。是以愚臣㥪㥪,实愿四州之牧守,独修务本之业,以堪四支之重。
陛下登基时,天下被判罪的人只有一百几十人;年年增多,达到五百多人了。百姓没有增多,刑法没有更加严苛。由此推究,这难道不是政治教化衰败、州郡长官不称职的明证吗?去年牛死亡,就全国平均而言,十头牛里损失两头;麦子收成不到一半,秋种还没有下地。如果二贼仍在边境上游荡,即使飞运草料、挽运粮食,千里补给也来不及。推究应对此事的办法,难道在于加强兵力吗?勇士精兵越多,越多就越有害罢了。天下如同人的身体,心腹充实,四肢即使有病,终究没有大的祸患;如今兖州、豫州、司州、冀州也是天下的心腹。因此愚臣怀着恳切之心,实在希望四州的牧守专心修治务农这个根本之业,来承受四肢的重负。
Since Your Majesty ascended the throne, the number condemned by courts throughout the realm has risen each year, from just over a hundred to more than five hundred. The population has not increased, nor have the laws grown harsher. Is this not clear proof that government and moral instruction are in decline, and that the Governors and Grand Administrators are not fit for their offices? In past years, two oxen in every ten died across the realm. This year, the wheat yielded less than half its former amount, and the autumn sowing has yet to begin. Should the two rebels continue to haunt the frontiers like wandering spirits, fodder and grain would have to be rushed forward, yet supplies transported a thousand Li would never arrive in time. Can strengthening the army truly provide the remedy? The more warriors we raise, the more grievously the realm will suffer. The realm is like the human body. If the heart and belly are strong, sickness in the four limbs will cause no grave harm. Today, Yan Province, Yu Province, Si Province, and Ji Province are the heart and belly of the realm. In my humble devotion, I therefore earnestly hope that the Governors and Grand Administrators of these four regions will devote themselves solely to strengthening the foundations, so that they may bear the burden of the four limbs.
然孤论难持,犯欲难成,众怨难积,疑似难分,故累载不为明主所察。凡言此者,类皆疏贱;疏贱之言,实未易听。若使善策必出于亲贵,亲贵固不犯四难以求忠爱,此古今之所常患也。」
然而孤立的议论难以坚持,触犯别人的私欲难以成功,众人的怨恨难以积聚,似是而非的情况难以分辨,所以多年来不被明主所察知。凡是说这些话的人,大多是被疏远、地位卑贱的人;疏远卑贱之人的话,实在不容易被听从。假如好的策略一定要出自亲近尊贵的人,亲近尊贵的人本来就绝不会冒犯这四种难处去求取忠爱,这是古往今来都常有的忧患。
Yet a lone opinion is hard to maintain, the ruler's wishes hard to oppose, the resentment of the many hard to bear, and truth hard to distinguish from falsehood. Thus such matters may escape even an enlightened ruler's notice for years. Those who speak of them are generally distant and lowly, and their words are never readily heard. If it is believed that sound counsel must come from intimates and dignitaries, such men will surely not brave these four difficulties merely for imperial favour. This has ever been a source of trouble in governing the realm, both in ancient times and today."
时又大议考课之制,以考内外众官。恕以为用不尽其人,虽才且无益,所存非所务,所务非世要。上疏曰:
当时又大规模议论考课制度,用来考核内外众官。杜恕认为用人不能让人尽其才,即使有才也没有益处;所关注的不是应致力的事情,所致力的事情也不是当世要务。于是上疏说:
At the time, there was also renewed debate over establishing a system to assess the performance of officials both at court and in the provinces. Du Shu held that unless men's talents were put to their proper use, talent itself was of no avail. Their duties made little use of their talents, and what they accomplished could not answer the needs of the age. He submitted a memorial to the throne:
「书称『 明试以功,三考黜陟』,诚帝王之盛制。使有能者当其官,有功者受其禄,譬犹乌获之举千钧,良、乐之选骥足也。虽历六代而考绩之法不著,关七圣而课试之文不垂,臣诚以为其法可粗依,其详难备举故也。语曰:『世有乱人而无乱法。』若使法可专任,则唐、虞可不须稷、契之佐,殷、周无贵伊、吕之辅矣。今奏考功者,陈周、汉之法为,终京房之本旨,可谓明考课之要矣。于以崇揖让之风,兴济济之治,臣以为未尽善也。
《尚书》中说:“明确地以功绩试用,经过三次考察决定降免或升迁。”这确实是帝王盛大的制度。让有才能的人担任相称的官职,让有功绩的人接受相应的俸禄,就好比乌获举起千钧重物,王良、伯乐选取骏马一样。虽然经历了六代,考绩的制度仍不显著;经过了七位圣人,课试的条文仍没有流传下来,我确实认为,这是因为考课的办法只能粗略地依循,而详细的条目难以完备列举的缘故。俗话说:“世上有作乱的人,却没有作乱的法。”假如法令可以单独依靠,那么唐、虞就不需要稷、契的辅佐,殷、周也不会看重伊尹、吕望的辅助了。如今上奏考功的人,陈述周、汉两代的法度,归结于京房的根本宗旨,可以说是明白了考课的要领。用它来推崇礼让的风气,兴起人才济济的治道,臣认为还没有达到尽善。
"The Documents says, 'Examine them clearly by their achievements; after three examinations, demote or advance them.' This is indeed a splendid institution for emperors and kings. It ensures that the able hold the offices suited to them and the meritorious receive their due emoluments, just as Wu Huo could lift a thousand jun and Wang Liang and Bo Le could pick out the finest steeds. Though this system passed through six dynasties without its regulations recorded, and through seven sage rulers without their writings on it transmitted to us, I believe this is because its broad principles may be followed, but its particulars cannot all be set forth. There is a saying: 'It is men who cause disorder, not laws.' If laws alone could be relied upon, Yao and Shun would not have needed the aid of Ji and Xie, nor would the Shang and Zhou have prized the assistance of Yi Yin and Lü Shang. Those who now memorialise on the assessment of merit expound the methods of the Zhou and Han, and continued Jing Fang's fundamental principles. They may be said to have elucidated the essentials of official assessment. Yet as a means of fostering a spirit of courteous deference and filling the government with worthy men, I, your servant, do not consider their proposals wholly satisfactory.
其欲使州郡考士,必由四科,皆有事效,然后察举,试辟公府,为亲民长吏,转以功次补郡守者,或就增秩赐爵,此最考课之急务也。臣以为便当显其身,用其言,使具为课州郡之法,法具施行,立必信之赏,施必行之罚。至于公卿及内职大臣,亦当俱以其职考课之也。古之三公,坐而论道,内职大臣,纳言补阙,无善不纪,无过不举。且天下至大,万机至众,诚非一明所能徧照。故君为元首,臣作股肱,明其一体相须而成也。
他们主张让州郡考察士人,必须通过四科,都要有实际成效,然后才加以考察举荐;由公府试用征召,担任亲近百姓的长吏,再按功绩和资历迁转补任郡守,有的便增加俸禄、赐给爵位,这是考核官员最急迫的事务。臣认为就应当表彰这些人,采纳他们的意见,让他们制定完备的考核州郡的办法;办法制定完备后即施行,设立必定信守的赏赐,施行必定执行的惩罚。至于公卿和内职大臣,也应当都根据各自的官职来考核。古代的三公,坐而论道;内职大臣,进献谏言、弥补缺失;没有善行不被记录,没有过失不被举发。况且天下极大,政务极多,实在不是一个人的明察所能遍照。所以君主是元首,臣属是股肱,表明他们是一体、相互依赖而成就事业的。
If the provinces and commanderies are to assess men, the Four Categories must be adopted, and only those with proven achievements in them should be recommended. Those recommended should then be recruited on trial to the offices of the Excellencies and appointed as magistrates governing the people. Thereafter, they may be promoted by merit to vacancies as commandery administrators, or receive increases in rank and grants of nobility. This is the most urgent task in the assessment of officials. II, your servant, believe that those whose proposals have merit should be brought to prominence and their views adopted. On this basis, comprehensive regulations should be drawn up for assessing the provinces and commanderies and then put into effect, with rewards made certain and punishments inexorable. The Excellencies, ministers, and officials of the inner court should likewise be assessed according to the duties of their offices. In ancient times, the Three Excellencies sat and discoursed upon the Way, while ministers of the inner court conveyed counsel and filled in what was lacking. No merit went unrecorded and no fault unreported. The realm is vast and its affairs innumerable; no single intelligence can illuminate them all. Thus the ruler is the head and his ministers the limbs: together they form a single body, and neither can accomplish its task without the other.
是以古人称廊庙之材,非一木之枝;帝王之业,非一士之略。由是言之,焉有大臣守职辨课可以致雍熙者哉!且布衣之交,犹有务信誓而蹈水火,感知己而披肝胆,徇声名而立节义者;况于束带立朝,致位卿相,所务者非特匹夫之信,所感者非徒知己之惠,所徇者岂声名而已乎!诸蒙宠禄受重任者,不徒欲举明主于唐、虞之上而已;身亦欲厕稷、契之列。是以古人不患于念治之心不尽,患于自任之意不足,此诚人主使之然也。
所以古人说:朝廷殿堂的木材,靠的不是一棵树上的枝条;帝王的功业,靠的也不是一个人的谋略。由此说来,哪有大臣只靠谨守本职、考辨课绩,就能带来雍熙太平的呢!况且平民百姓之间的交往,尚且有人为信守誓约而赴汤蹈火,为感激知己而披肝沥胆,为追求声名而树立节义;何况那些束带立于朝堂、官至卿相的人,他们所务求的不只是匹夫的信义,所感念的不只是知己的恩惠,所追求的难道只是声名而已吗!那些蒙受恩宠和俸禄而担当重任的人,不只是想把明主推举到唐、虞之上;他们自身也想置身于稷、契的行列。所以古人不担心自己求治的心意不够竭尽,而担心自己担当重任的意愿不够;这确实是君主使他们这样的。
Therefore the ancients said that the timber for palaces and temples cannot come from a single tree, nor can an emperor's enterprise rest on the strategy of a single man. How, then, could great ministers bring about harmonious prosperity merely by keeping to their posts and assessment duties? Even friendships among commoners produce men who honour their pledges and brave fire and water, who bare their hearts in gratitude to those who understand them, and who uphold integrity at the cost of their lives for the sake of their good name. How much more so for those who don court robes, take their place among the ranks of officials, and rise to the highest ministerial offices? What these ministers pursue rises above the fidelity of an ordinary man; what moves them goes beyond the favour of one who understands them. Can it be that all they seek is merely reputation? Those entrusted with favour, emolument, and grave responsibilities seek not only to raise an enlightened ruler above Tang and Yu; they also aspire to rank alongside Ji and Xie. Thus the ancients did not fear that they lacked the desire to govern the realm well, but that they lacked the resolve to take its responsibilities upon themselves. That ministers should possess such resolve is, in truth, the work of their ruler.
唐、虞之君,委任稷、契、夔、龙而责成功,及其罪也,殛鲧而放四凶。今大臣亲奉明诏,给事目下,其有夙夜在公,恪勤特立,当官不挠贵势,执平不阿所私,危言危行以处朝廷者,自明主所察也。若尸禄以为高,拱嘿以为智,当官苟在于免负,立朝不忘于容身,絜行逊言以处朝廷者,亦明主所察也。诚使容身保位,无放退之辜,而尽节在公,抱见疑之势,公义不修而私议成俗,虽仲尼为谋,犹不能尽一才,又况于世俗之人乎!
唐、虞的君主,任用稷、契、夔、龙而要求他们成就事功;等到臣子有罪时,就处死鲧、放逐四凶。如今大臣们亲自领受圣明的诏令,在君主眼前供职。其中那些日夜为公事操劳,恭敬勤恳、特立出众,任职时不屈服于权贵势力,执法公正而不偏私,以正言正行立于朝廷的人,自然会被明主明察。至于那些把空受俸禄不理事当作清高,把拱手沉默不议政当作智慧,在官位上只求免除罪责,在朝堂上念念不忘保全自身,行为收敛、言语谦退而置身朝廷的人,也同样是明主所能明察的。如果真的让那些只顾保全自身、保住职位的人没有放逐罢退的罪责,而让那些为公家竭尽节操的人抱着被猜疑的处境,公正的道义得不到树立,而徇私的议论成为风气,那么即使是仲尼来出谋划策,尚且不能让一个人才充分施展他的才能,又何况世间平常的人呢!
The sovereigns of Tang and Yu entrusted office to Ji, Xie, Kui, and Long, and held them responsible for success. When offences arose, they put Gun to death and banished the Four Evildoers. Today, the great ministers receive the enlightened sovereign's commands in person and serve beneath his very gaze. Those who labour for the public good from dawn till dusk, who are scrupulous and independent, who do not yield in office to the power of the great, who uphold impartiality without favouring their intimates, and who remain upright in word and deed at court, are known to an enlightened ruler. Those who pride themselves on drawing their salaries without rendering service, who regard folded hands and silence as wisdom, who seek only to avoid blame in office and preserve their standing at court, conducting themselves cautiously and speaking deferentially, are likewise known to an enlightened ruler. If ministers must think only of protecting themselves and preserving their positions to avoid fault that might lead to dismissal, while those who devote themselves wholeheartedly to public affairs instead fall under suspicion, then public righteousness will go unfulfilled while selfish private opinions become the prevailing custom. Even if Confucius devised the system, he could not make full use of every man's abilities; how much less could ordinary men do so?
今之学者,师商、韩而上法术,竞以儒家为迂阔,不周世用,此最风俗之流弊,创业者之所致慎也。」后考课竟不行。
现在的学者,效法商鞅、韩非而崇尚法度和权术,争相认为儒家学说迂阔而不切合当世之用,这是风俗中最严重的流弊,也是创业者最应当谨慎的。后来,考课制度终究没有施行。
Scholars today take Shang Yang and Han Fei as their masters and exalt Legalist methods. They compete with one another in dismissing the Confucians as pedantic and impractical, unfit for the needs of the age. This is the gravest corruption of the prevailing custom, and those who found great enterprises must guard against it with particular care." In the end, the new system for evaluating officials was not implemented.
The New Book of Du Clan states: At the time, Li Feng was a Regular Attendant. Yuan Kan, Gentleman within the Yellow Gates, was transferred to the post of Personnel Section Gentleman, while Xun Yu was appointed Grand Administrator of Dong Commandery. Both were Du Shu's colleagues and close friends.
乐安廉昭以才能拔擢,颇好言事。恕上疏极谏曰:
乐安的廉昭因有才能而被提拔,很喜欢议论政事。杜恕上疏极力劝谏说:
Lian Zhao of Le'an was promoted for his abilities and was rather fond of commenting on affairs. Du Su submitted a memorial remonstrating strongly:
「伏见尚书郎廉昭奏左丞曹璠以罚当关不依诏,坐判问。又云「诸当坐者别奏」。尚书令陈矫自奏不敢辞罚,亦不敢以处重为恭,意至恳恻。臣窃愍然为朝廷惜之!夫圣人不择世而兴,不易民而治,然而生必有贤智之佐者,盖进之以道,率之以礼故也。古之帝王之所以能辅世长民者,莫不远得百姓之懽心,近尽群臣之智力。诚使今朝任职之臣皆天下之选,而不能尽其力,不可谓能使人;若非天下之选,亦不可谓能官人。
我看到尚书郎廉昭奏称:左丞曹璠因处罚应当报告却没有依诏令办理,被治罪审问;又奏说“其他应当治罪的人另行上奏”。尚书令陈矫亲自上奏说,自己不敢推避处罚,但也不敢以加重处罚来表示恭敬,情意十分恳切悲恻。我私下里感到忧伤,替朝廷惋惜这件事。圣人不会选择时代才兴起,也不会更换民众才治理;然而他们兴起时必定有贤能智慧的辅佐者,这大概是因为用道义进用他们、用礼法统率他们的缘故。古代的帝王之所以能辅佐世道、统领百姓,没有不是远能得到百姓的欢心、近能使群臣充分发挥才智和力量的。如果如今在朝廷任职的臣子都是天下推选出来的人才,却不能让他们充分发挥力量,就不能说是会用人;如果他们不是天下推选出来的人才,也不能说是会委任官员。
"I have seen the memorial of Imperial Secretariat Gentleman Lian Zhao, accusing Cao Fan, the Imperial Secretariat Left Assistant, of imposing punishments contrary to the orders outlined in the imperial edicts. Cao Fan was tried and questioned. He further stated: 'All others who should be held culpable are to be reported separately.' Chen Jiao, Director of the Imperial Secretariat, has submitted a memorial declaring that he dares not evade punishment, nor impose heavy penalties. His words are most earnest and heartfelt. I am deeply grieved and regret this for the sake of the court. Sages do not choose their age before arising, nor choose another people to govern. Yet worthy and wise men invariably come forward to assist them, because they are advanced in accordance with the Way and guided by ritual. The emperors and kings of old could uphold their age and govern the people, because they won the willing allegiance of the common people throughout the realm and drew fully upon the wisdom and strength of their ministers at court. If those now holding office are indeed the finest men in the realm, yet cannot exercise their abilities to the full, then it cannot be said that men are being properly employed. If they are not the finest men in the realm, then it cannot be said that appointments are being properly made.
陛下忧劳万机,或亲灯火,而庶事不康,刑禁日弛,岂非股肱不称之明效欤?原其所由,非独臣有不尽忠,亦主有不能使。百里奚愚于虞而智于秦,豫让苟容中行而著节智伯,斯则古人之明验矣。今臣言一朝皆不忠,是诬一朝也;然其事类,可推而得。陛下感帑藏之不充实,而军事未息,至乃断四时之赋衣,薄御府之私谷,帅由圣意,举朝称明,与闻政事密勿大臣,宁有恳恳忧此者乎?
陛下日理万机,忧心劳苦,有时甚至夜以继日;然而各项事务并不顺利,刑法禁令日渐松弛,这难道不是股肱大臣不称职的明显效验吗?推究其中的缘由,不只是臣下有不尽忠之处,也是君主有不能任用人才的地方。百里奚在虞国显得愚钝,在秦国却显得有智慧;豫让在中行氏那里只求苟且容身,在智伯那里却显扬节操,这就是古人显著的验证了。现在我说满朝官员都不忠,这是在诬蔑满朝官员;但同类的情况,可以推究得出。陛下为国库不充实而忧虑,而战事还没有停息,甚至停止四时分赐的衣服,减少御府中私用的粮食,这些都出自圣意,满朝都称赞陛下英明;那些参与机要政事的大臣,难道有谁恳切地忧虑这些事吗?
Your Majesty wears yourself out over the myriad affairs of state, sometimes personally labouring by lamplight, Yet public affairs remain unsettled, and the enforcement of the laws grows more lax by the day. Is this not clear proof that your ministers are unequal to their responsibilities? If we seek the cause, it lies not only in ministers failing to give their full loyalty, but also in a ruler's inability to employ them. Baili Xi seemed a fool in Yu but proved wise in Qin; Yu Rang merely held his place under Zhonghang, but won renown for his fidelity to Zhi Bo. These are clear precedents from antiquity. Were I to say that the entire court is disloyal, I would be slandering the entire court. Yet the truth may be inferred from the nature of events. Distressed that the treasury remains depleted while warfare continues unabated, Your Majesty has gone so far as to discontinue the seasonal provision of robes and reduce the grain reserved for imperial use. These measures were Your Majesty's own initiative, and the whole court acclaimed your wisdom. Yet among the senior ministers privy to affairs of state, has any shown heartfelt concern over matters like this?
骑都尉王才、幸乐人孟思所为不法,振动京都,而其罪状发于小吏,公卿大臣初无一言。自陛下践阼以来,司隷校尉、御史中丞宁有举纲维以督奸宄,使朝廷肃然者邪?若陛下以为今世无良才,朝廷乏贤佐,岂可追望稷、契之遐踪,坐待来世之俊乂乎!今之所谓贤者,尽有大官而享厚禄矣,然而奉上之节未立,向公之心不一者,委任之责不专,而俗多忌讳故也。臣以为忠臣不必亲,亲臣不必忠。何者?以其居无嫌之地而事得自尽也。
骑都尉王才和受宠幸的乐人孟思的所作所为不合法度,震动了京都,而他们的罪状是由小吏揭发出来的,公卿大臣起初一句话也没有说。自从陛下即位以来,司隶校尉、御史中丞难道有谁伸张纲纪法度来督察奸邪,使朝廷整肃的吗?如果陛下认为当今之世没有良才,朝廷缺乏贤能的辅佐,难道可以追慕稷、契遥远的踪迹,坐等后世才德出众的人吗!如今所谓贤能的人,都已经做了大官、享受厚禄了;然而他们侍奉君上的节操没有树立,为公家办事的心意不专一,原因就在于委派给他们的职责不专一,而世俗中多有忌讳的缘故。臣认为忠臣不一定要与君主亲近,与君主亲近的臣子不一定忠诚。为什么呢?因为他们处在没有嫌疑的地位,做起事来能够竭尽自己的心力。
The unlawful acts of Wang Cai, Commandant of Cavalry, and Meng Si, a favoured entertainer, shook the capital, yet their crimes were exposed by a petty official, while the highest ministers initially said not a word. Since Your Majesty ascended the throne, has any Colonel of the Capital or Deputy Imperial Censor upheld law and discipline, curbed wickedness, and inspired awe throughout the court? If Your Majesty believes that this age has no men of worth and the court lacks able counsellors, are we then merely admiring the distant example of Ji and Xie, while sitting idle and awaiting the outstanding men of a future age? Those now deemed worthy all hold high office and enjoy generous stipends. Yet they have shown neither steadfast devotion to their sovereign nor single-minded dedication to the public good. This is because responsibility is not entrusted exclusively, while prevailing custom imposes too many restraints. I, your servant, believe that a loyal minister need not be close to the sovereign, nor is a close minister necessarily loyal. Why is this? Because when a man occupies a position that gives no cause for suspicion, he can devote himself wholly to his duties.
今有疏者毁人不实其所毁,而必曰私报所憎,誉人不实其所誉,而必曰私爱所亲,左右或因之以进憎爱之说。非独毁誉有之,政事损益,亦皆有嫌。陛下当思所以阐广朝臣之心,笃厉有道之节,使之自同古人,望与竹帛耳。反使如廉昭者扰乱其间,臣惧大臣遂将容身保位,坐观得失,为来世戒也!
如今,如果有与陛下关系疏远的人批评别人,而批评的内容不符合事实,人们就一定会说他是私下报复自己憎恨的人;如果他称赞别人,而称赞的内容不符合事实,人们就一定会说他是偏爱自己亲近的人。陛下身边的人有的还会借此进献带有个人爱憎的言论。不只是批评和称赞有这种情况,政事上的增损变革,也都同样会招来猜疑。陛下应当考虑如何开阔朝臣们的心胸,砥砺有德之士的节操,使他们自觉地向古人看齐,期望他们能留名竹帛。反而让像廉昭这样的人从中扰乱,我担心大臣们将会只顾容身保位,坐观朝政得失,成为后世的鉴戒!
Now, when a distant minister criticises someone, Your Majesty suspects that he is privately taking revenge on one he hates; when he praises someone, Your Majesty suspects that he is privately favouring one close to him. Those around Your Majesty may then take the opportunity to allege their own personal likes and dislikes, and so distant ministers dare no longer offer either criticism or praise. It is not only praise and censure that are affected; every proposal to alter government policy likewise arouses suspicion. I hope Your Majesty will consider how to give freer scope to the minds of your ministers at court and strengthen the integrity of men, so that they may model themselves on the ancients and aspire only to leave their names in the histories. Instead, men such as Lian Zhao are allowed to sow confusion among them. I fear that henceforth the great ministers will seek only to protect themselves and preserve their positions, sitting by as affairs prosper or fail, leaving a warning to generations to come!
昔周公戒鲁侯曰「无使大臣怨乎不以」,言贤愚明皆当世用也。尧数舜之功,称去四凶,不言大小,有罪则去也。今者朝臣不自以为不能,以陛下为不任也;不自以为不知,以陛下为不问也。陛下何不遵周公之所以用,大舜之所以去?使侍中、尚书坐则侍帷幄,行则从华辇,亲对诏问,所陈必达,则群臣之行能否,皆可得而知;忠能者进,暗劣者退,谁敢依违而不自尽?
从前周公告诫鲁侯说:“不要让大臣因为不被任用而怨恨。”这是说,不论贤能还是愚陋的人,都应当为当世所任用。尧列举舜的功绩,称赞他除去四凶,而不说四凶罪过的大小,只要有罪就除去。如今朝臣不认为自己没有才能,却认为陛下不任用他们;不认为自己没有才智,却认为陛下不询问他们。陛下为什么不遵循周公用人的原则、大舜除人的原则呢?让侍中、尚书在您安坐时就侍奉在帷幄旁,出行时就跟随在华辇后,亲自应答诏问,所陈述的意见必定上达;这样,群臣的操行和能力如何,就都可以得知了。忠诚而有才能的人进用,昏愚低劣的人斥退,谁还敢犹豫迟疑而不竭尽自己的心力呢?
Long ago, the Duke of Zhou admonished the Marquis of Lu: 'Do not let great ministers resent being left unemployed.' He meant that the worthy and unworthy should be clearly distinguished and employed as the age required. When Yao recounted Shun's achievements, he praised him for casting out the Four Villains. He made no distinction of rank: whoever was guilty was removed. Court officials today do not believe themselves incapable, but believe that Your Majesty has failed to employ them; they do not believe themselves ignorant, but believe that Your Majesty has failed to consult them. Why does Your Majesty not follow the Duke of Zhou's principles in employing men and the Great Shun's principles in dismissing them? Let the Palace Attendants and officials of the Imperial Secretariat attend within the curtains when Your Majesty is seated and accompany the splendid carriage when you travel. Let them personally answer your questions, so that every voice may reach you. Then the conduct and abilities of every minister may be known. Advance the loyal and capable, and dismiss the benighted and inferior. Who then would dare equivocate rather than exert himself to the utmost?
以陛下之圣明,亲与群臣论议政事,使群臣人得自尽,人自以为亲,人思所以报,贤愚能否,在陛下之所用。以此治事,何事不办?以此建功,何功不成?每有军事,诏书常曰:「谁当忧此者邪?吾当自忧耳。」近诏又曰:「忧公忘私者必不然,但先公后私即自办也。」伏读明诏,乃知圣思究尽下情,然亦怪陛下不治其本而忧其末也。人之能否,实有本性,虽臣亦以为朝臣不尽称职也。
凭陛下的圣明,亲自与群臣议论政事,使群臣人人都能尽自己的心力,人人都觉得自己与陛下亲近,人人都想着如何报答;人的贤愚、能干与否,全在于陛下如何任用。用这样的做法处理政事,有什么事办不成?用这样的做法建立功业,有什么功业建不成?每当有军事时,诏书常常说:“谁该为这事忧虑呢?我应当自己忧虑罢了。”近来的诏书又说:“公而忘私不一定做得到,但先公后私,事情自然就办好了。”我恭敬地拜读圣明的诏书,才知道陛下的圣明思虑完全体察了下情;然而我也对陛下不治理根本却忧虑末节感到不解。人的能干与否,确实有天赋本性;即便是臣也认为朝臣并不都称职。
With Your Majesty's sagacity, you personally deliberate affairs of government with your ministers, allowing each to exert himself to the utmost. Each feels close to you and considers how he may repay you. Whether men prove worthy or mediocre, capable or incapable, depends entirely on how Your Majesty employs them. What affair could not be managed in this way? What achievement could not be attained? Whenever military matters arise, edicts invariably say, 'Who should bear this concern? I shall bear it myself.' A recent edict also said, 'Men cannot truly be expected to serve the public good and forget private interests. It is enough that they put public concerns before private ones, and affairs will naturally be accomplished.' On humbly reading this enlightened edict, I saw that Your Majesty's sagacious thought had fully fathomed the sentiments of those below. Yet I also venture to suggest that Your Majesty may be concerning yourself with the consequences rather than addressing the root. Whether a man is capable or not does indeed depend on his innate nature, and even I believe that not all the ministers at court are equal to their offices.
明主之用人也,使能者不敢遗其力,而不能者不得处非其任。选举非其人,未必为有罪也;举朝共容非其人,乃为怪耳。陛下知其不尽力也,而代之忧其职,知其不能也,而教之治其事,岂徒主劳而臣逸哉?虽圣贤并世,终不能以此为治也。陛下又患台阁禁令之不密,人事请属之不绝,听伊尹作迎客出入之制,选司徒更恶吏以守寺门;威禁由之,实未得为禁之本也。
圣明的君主任用人时,使有才能的人不敢不竭尽自己的力量,使没有才能的人不得处在不适合他的职位上。选拔举荐的人不合适,不一定是有罪;满朝上下共同容忍那个不合适的人,才是怪事。陛下知道他们不尽心尽力,却替他们忧虑他们分内的事务;知道他们没有才能,却教他们处理事务,这难道只是君主劳苦而臣下安逸吗?即使圣贤同处一世,终究不能靠这种做法来治理国家。陛下又担心台阁的禁令不严密,人事请托不断绝,让伊尹制定迎客出入的制度,又让司徒选更凶恶的吏员来把守台阁;威严的禁令由此得以施行,其实并没有抓住禁令的根本。
An enlightened ruler employs men so that the able dare not withhold their utmost efforts, while the incapable cannot remain in posts beyond their competence. To select the wrong man is not necessarily culpable; what is extraordinary is for the whole court to tolerate him. Your Majesty knows that such men do not exert themselves fully, yet worries about their offices on their behalf; knows that they are incapable, yet instructs them in the conduct of their duties. Can this result in anything but toil for the ruler and ease for his ministers? Even if sages and worthies all arose in the same age, order could not be brought to the realm in this way. Your Majesty is also troubled that prohibitions within the palace and departments are not strictly enforced, and that private solicitations and appeals never cease. Even if Yi Yin himself framed rules governing the reception and passage of visitors, and the Excellency over the Masses appointed sterner clerks to guard the office gates, such measures might enforce obedience through fear, but they would not address the root of the abuse.
昔汉安帝时,少府窦嘉辟廷尉郭躬无罪之兄子,犹见举奏,章劾纷纷。近司隷校尉孔羡辟大将军狂悖之弟,而有司嘿尔,望风希指,甚于受属。选举不以实,人事之大者也。嘉有亲戚之宠,躬非社稷重臣,犹尚如此;以今况古,陛下自不督必行之罚以绝阿党之原耳。伊尹之制,与恶吏守门,非治世之具也。使臣之言少蒙察纳,何患于奸不削灭,而养若昭等乎!
从前汉安帝时,少府窦嘉征召了廷尉郭躬那个无罪的侄子,尚且被人检举上奏,弹劾的奏章纷纷不断。近来司隶校尉孔羡征召了大将军那个狂妄悖逆的弟弟,而有关官员却默不作声,看风使舵、迎合意旨,比接受请托还要严重。选拔举荐不依据实情,是人事上重大的问题。窦嘉有外戚的宠幸,郭躬不是国家重臣,尚且如此;拿今天的情况比照古代,陛下自己没有督促必须实行的刑罚来杜绝结党营私的根源罢了。伊尹的制度,让凶恶吏员守门,不是治理天下的办法。假使我的话能稍加审察采纳,又何必担心奸邪不能消灭,哪里还用养着像廉昭等人呢?
During the reign of Emperor An of Han, Dou Jia, the Minister of the Lesser Treasury, recruited an innocent nephew of Guo Gong, the Commandant of Justice. Even so, he was impeached, and memorials denouncing him came in a flood. Recently, Kong Xian, Colonel of the Capital, recruited the Grand General's arrogant and unruly younger brother, yet the responsible officials remained silent, watching the prevailing winds and seeking to anticipate his wishes. This was worse than yielding to private solicitation. To make appointments without regard to merit is a matter of the gravest consequence. Dou Jia enjoyed favour as an imperial kinsman, while Guo Gong was no minister on whom the dynasty's survival depended, yet even then the response was such. Compared with the past, the present state of affairs exists only because Your Majesty does not personally ensure that punishment is inexorably enforced, thereby cutting off favouritism and faction at their source. The institutions of Yi Yin and the posting of wicked officials at the gates are no instruments for governing an orderly age. If my words should receive even the slightest consideration, why should treachery not be rooted out? Why continue to tolerate the likes of Lian Zhao?
Your servant Songzhi notes that the Grand General was Sima Yi (posthumously honoured as King Xuan, the Renowned King). The Book of Jin states: "King Xuan's fifth younger brother, named Tong, served as an aide to the Colonel of the Capital." I suspect he was the reckless and rebellious man mentioned by Du Shu. Sima Tong's son Sima Shun was enfeoffed as Neighbourhood Marquis of Longyang. When Jin first accepted the abdication from Wei, Sima Shun refused to recognise Heaven's mandate and remained steadfast in his allegiance. He was stripped of his title and fief and exiled to Wuwei.
夫纠擿奸宄,忠事也,然而世憎小人行之者,以其不顾道理而苟求容进也。若陛下不复考其终始,必以违众忤世为奉公,密行白人为尽节,焉有通人大才而更不能为此邪?诚顾道理而弗为耳。使天下皆背道而趋利,则人主之所最病者,陛下将何乐焉,胡不绝其萌乎!夫先意承旨以求容美,率皆天下浅薄无行义者,其意务在于适人主之心而已,非欲治天下安百姓也。陛下何不试变业而示之,彼岂执其所守以违圣意哉?夫人臣得人主之心,安业也;处尊显之官,荣事也;食千钟之禄,厚实也。
纠察举报奸邪作恶之人,本是忠诚的事;然而世人憎恶小人去做这种事,因为他们不顾道理,只是苟且谋求被容纳和进用。如果陛下不再考察事情的始末,就一定会把违背众人、忤逆世俗当作奉公,把暗中告发别人当作尽节;哪里有通达事理、才能卓越的人反而做不来这些呢?只不过他们顾念道理而不肯去做罢了。假如天下人都背弃道义而追逐利益,那就是君主最担忧的事,陛下还有什么可高兴的,为什么不斩断它的萌芽呢!那些预先揣摩君主心意、承奉意旨来求得接纳和赞美的人,全都是天下浅薄、没有品行道义的人;他们的心思只在于迎合君主的心意罢了,并不是想治理天下、安定百姓。陛下为什么不试着改变一贯的做法来给他们看看,他们难道会坚持自己原来所守的东西而违背圣意吗?作为臣子,得到君主的欢心,是安稳的事业;处在尊贵显要的官职上,是荣耀的事;享受千钟的俸禄,是丰厚的实利。
To expose and denounce treachery is an act of loyalty. Yet the world despises petty men who do so, because they disregard principle and seek only favour and advancement. If Your Majesty does not examine their conduct from beginning to end, you will inevitably mistake defying the multitude and offending the world for devotion to the public good, and secretly informing against others for the utmost loyalty. Could men of broad understanding and great ability truly be incapable of such things? They refrain only because they have regard for principle. If all under Heaven were to forsake the Way and pursue profit, this would be a ruler's gravest affliction. What pleasure could Your Majesty take in it? Why not suppress it at its first stirrings? Those who anticipate the ruler's wishes and bend to his will in pursuit of favour and praise are most likely shallow men devoid of honour. Their sole concern is to gratify the ruler, not to govern the realm or bring peace to the people. Might Your Majesty not alter your course as a test and make your wishes known to them? Would they then cling to their principles in defiance of your sacred will? For a minister, winning his ruler's favour secures his position; holding a high and eminent office brings honour; and receiving a stipend of a thousand zhong brings abundant wealth.
人臣虽愚,未有不乐此而喜干迕者也,迫于道,自彊耳。诚以为陛下当怜而佑之,少委任焉,如何反录昭等倾侧之意,而忽若人者乎?今者外有伺隙之寇,内有贫旷之民,陛下当大计天下之损益,政事之得失,诚不可以怠也。」恕在朝八年,其论议亢直,皆此类也。
做臣子的即使愚笨,也没有不乐于如此、反而喜爱冒犯君主的;只是迫于道义,才勉强自己这样做罢了。我确实认为陛下应当怜悯并护佑他们,对他们稍加委任;怎么反而采纳廉昭等人倾侧不正的意见,却忽视像这样的人呢?如今外有窥伺可乘之机的敌寇,内有贫困匮乏的百姓,陛下应当好好考虑天下的利弊、政事的得失,实在不可以懈怠。杜恕在朝为官八年,他的议论刚正直率,都像这样。
No minister, however foolish, would forgo these benefits and instead go against his ruler's will. He does so only because duty compels him, forcing himself to speak out. He does so only because duty compels him, steeling himself to speak. I truly believe that such men deserve Your Majesty's care and support, and should be granted some measure of trust. How could the subversive designs of Zhao and his associates be heeded, while men of this kind are disregarded? Abroad, enemies watch for an opening; at home, the people are impoverished and neglected. I respectfully hope that Your Majesty will carefully weigh the gains and losses of the realm and the successes and failures of government, and will not permit the slightest remissness." Du Shu served at court for eight years, and his arguments were invariably as uncompromising and forthright as this.
出为弘农太守,数岁转赵相,以疾去官。起家为河东太守,岁余,迁淮北都督护军,复以疾去。恕所在,务存大体而已,其树惠爱,益得百姓欢心,不及于畿。顷之,拜御史中丞。恕在朝廷,以不得当世之和,故屡在外任。复出为幽州刺史,加建威将军,使持节,护乌丸校尉。时征北将军程喜屯蓟,尚书袁侃等戒恕曰:「程申伯处先帝之世,倾田国让于青州。足下今俱杖节,使共屯一城,宜深有以待之。」而恕不以为意。
杜恕出任弘农太守,几年后转任赵相,因病离职。后来又被从家中起用为河东太守,一年多后,升迁为淮北都督护军,又因病离职。杜恕在任职之处,只致力于顾全大体而已;他树立恩惠仁爱,越来越得到百姓欢心,但比不上杜畿。不久,杜恕被任命为御史中丞。杜恕在朝廷,因为不能与当世之人融洽相处,所以屡次出外任职。后来又出任幽州刺史,加授建威将军,使持节,并任护乌丸校尉。当时,征北将军程喜驻扎在蓟城,尚书袁侃等人告诫杜恕说:“程申伯在先帝的时候,曾在青州排挤田国让。如今您与他都执持节杖,同驻一城,应当深加防备,妥善对待他。”但杜恕不以为意。
Thereafter, Du Su was reinstated as Grand Administrator of Hongnong. After several years, he was transferred to serve as Principality Chancellor of Zhao State, but resigned owing to illness. He was later recalled as Grand Administrator of Hedong. A year or so later, Du Su was promoted to Protector of the Provincial Army north of the Huai River, but again resigned owing to illness. Wherever Du Shu served, he concerned himself chiefly with the larger principles of government. In governing with kindness and winning the people's affection, he did not equal his father, Du Ji. Before long, Du Su was appointed Deputy Imperial Censor. At court, Du Shu would not conform to the ways of his contemporaries, and was therefore repeatedly assigned to posts outside the capital. He was again sent out as Inspector of You Province, with the additional titles General Who Establishes Might, Envoy Bearing the Imperial Tally and Colonel Protecting the Wuhuan. At the time, Cheng Xi, General Who Conquers the North, was garrisoned at Ji. Imperial Secretariat Yuan Kan and others warned Du Shu: "Under the late emperor, Cheng Shenbo forced Tian Guorang out of Qing Province. You now both bear imperial tallies and are to garrison the same city. You should take great care in dealing with him." Du Shu paid no heed.
《魏略》曰:恕在弘农,宽和有惠爱。及迁,以孟康代恕为弘农。康字公休,安平人。黄初中,以于郭后有外属,并受九亲赐拜,遂转为散骑侍郎。是时,散骑皆以高才英儒充其选,而康独缘妃嫱杂在其间,故于时皆共轻之,号为阿九。康既无才敏,因在宂官,博读书传,后遂有所弹駮,其文义雅而切要,众人乃更加意。正始中,出为弘农,领典农校尉。康到官,清己奉职,嘉善而矜不能,省息狱讼,缘民所欲,因而利之。
The Weilüe / Brief History of Wei states: While Du Shu was in Hongnong, he governed with leniency and restraint, and showed benevolent care for the people. When he was reassigned, Meng Kang succeeded him in Hongnong. Meng Kang, courtesy name Gongxiu, was a native of Anping. During the Huangchu era, owing to his Ninefold kinship with Empress Guo, he received imperial bestowments and appointments. He was subsequently transferred to Cavalier Attendant Gentleman. At the time, the post was filled by men of outstanding talent and eminent scholars. Meng Kang alone had gained his position through his connection to an imperial consort, so his contemporaries all looked down on him and called him "A-Jiu" (the ninth). Though lacking in talent and quick wit, Meng Kang used the leisure afforded by his sinecure to read widely in the classics and commentaries. He later wrote impeachments and critiques whose arguments were elegant and incisive, and people began to regard him more highly. During the Zhengshi era, Meng Kang was sent out to govern Hongnong, concurrently serving as Colonel Directing Agriculture. On taking office, Meng Kang lived with integrity and fulfilled his duties faithfully. He commended the worthy and showed compassion to those of limited ability. He reduced litigation and imprisonment, accommodated the people's wishes, and sought thereby to benefit them.
郡领吏二百余人,涉春遣休,常四分遣一。事无宿诺,时出案行,皆豫𠡠督邮平水,不得令属官遣人探候,修设曲敬。又不欲烦损吏民,常豫𠡠吏卒,行各持镰,所在自刈马草,不止亭传,露宿树下,又所从常不过十余人。郡带道路,其诸过賔客,自非公法无所出给;若知旧造之,自出于家。康之始拜,众人虽知其有志量,以其未尝宰牧,不保其能也;而康恩泽治能乃尔,吏民称歌焉。嘉平末,徙渤海太守,征入为中书令,后转为监。
The commandery employed more than two hundred officials. Each spring, he granted them leave in batches, one quarter at a time. He never left a promise unfulfilled overnight. Whenever he went out on tours of inspection, he instructed the waterways officials and Post Marshals in advance not to let subordinate offices send men to watch for his arrival or make elaborate preparations to receive him. Unwilling to burden officials or people, he ordered his attendants to carry sickles whenever they travelled, so that they could cut fodder for the horses themselves. He did not lodge at post stations, but slept in the open beneath the trees, and his retinue never exceeded a dozen or so men. For those passing through the commandery, unless they were on official business, Meng Kang strictly observed the regulations and provided them with nothing. If old friends or acquaintances came to visit, he supplied their needs from his own household. When Meng Kang was first appointed, people recognised his ambition and sound judgement, but as he had never before governed a commandery or province, they doubted his ability. Yet he governed with such benevolence and skill that officials and people alike sang his praises. At the end of the Jiaping era, he was transferred to serve as Grand Administrator of Bohai. He was later recalled to the capital as Director of the Palace Secretariat and subsequently promoted to Supervisor of the Palace Secretariat.
《魏略》曰:恕在弘农,宽和有惠爱。及迁,以孟康代恕为弘农。康字公休,安平人。黄初中,以于郭后有外属,并受九亲赐拜,遂转为散骑侍郎。是时,散骑皆以高才英儒充其选,而康独缘妃嫱杂在其间,故于时皆共轻之,号为阿九。康既无才敏,因在宂官,博读书传,后遂有所弹駮,其文义雅而切要,众人乃更加意。正始中,出为弘农,领典农校尉。康到官,清己奉职,嘉善而矜不能,省息狱讼,缘民所欲,因而利之。
《魏略》记载:杜恕在弘农任职时,宽厚温和,对百姓有仁爱之心。等到杜恕升迁的时候,朝廷任用孟康代替杜恕担任弘农太守。孟康字公休,是安平人。黄初年间,因为与郭皇后有外戚关系,孟康连同九族亲属一同受到赏赐封官,于是转任散骑侍郎。当时散骑侍郎的职位都是由才能卓越、学识渊博的大儒来担任的,而孟康只是因为与郭皇后有外戚关系才得以在其中任职,所以当时的人都轻视他,给他取了个外号叫“阿九”。孟康本来并没有敏捷的才思,因为担任的是闲散官职,他就广泛地阅读典籍,后来就提出了一些弹劾和批驳的奏章,他的文辞义理既典雅又切中要害,大家于是才对他更加留意。正始年间,孟康外任弘农太守,兼任典农校尉。孟康到任后,清廉自律,恪尽职守,嘉奖贤善之人,怜悯能力不足之人,减少诉讼案件,顺着百姓的愿望,顺势为他们谋取利益。
郡领吏二百余人,涉春遣休,常四分遣一。事无宿诺,时出案行,皆豫𠡠督邮平水,不得令属官遣人探候,修设曲敬。又不欲烦损吏民,常豫𠡠吏卒,行各持镰,所在自刈马草,不止亭传,露宿树下,又所从常不过十余人。郡带道路,其诸过賔客,自非公法无所出给;若知旧造之,自出于家。康之始拜,众人虽知其有志量,以其未尝宰牧,不保其能也;而康恩泽治能乃尔,吏民称歌焉。嘉平末,徙渤海太守,征入为中书令,后转为监。
弘农郡管辖的官吏有两百多人,春季期间安排他们休假,常常派遣四分之一的官吏放假,承诺的事务从不隔夜未完成。他时常外出巡视,都预先告诫督邮、平水,不许让下属官员派人探听伺候,曲意逢迎。又不想烦扰损害官吏百姓。他常常预先告诫官吏士兵,出行时各自带着镰刀,在所到之处自己割马草,不在驿站停留,露天睡在树下。而且他所带领的随从常常不超过十多人。弘农郡地处交通要道。对于那些过往的宾客,如果并非出于公事之需,官府就不提供任何供给;如果是熟悉的老朋友造访,则自己从家中拿出东西款待。孟康刚被任命时,众人虽然知道他有志向和度量,因为他未曾担任过地方长官,所以不敢保证他能胜任。然而孟康的恩惠和治理才能如此卓著,官吏和百姓都称赞歌颂他。嘉平末年,他调任渤海太守,被征召入朝担任中书令,后来转任中书监。
至官未期,有鲜卑大人儿,不由关塞,径将数十骑诣州,州斩所从来小子一人,无表言上。喜于是劾奏恕,下廷尉,当死。以父畿勤事水死,免为庶人,徙章武郡,是岁嘉平元年。恕倜傥任意,而思不防患,终致此败。
杜恕到任还不满一年,有个鲜卑大人的儿子不经过关塞,径直带领几十名骑兵来到州府,州府斩杀了跟随他前来的一个年轻人,却没有上表奏报朝廷。程喜于是上奏弹劾杜恕,杜恕被交付廷尉,判为死罪。因父亲杜畿勤于国事、死于水中,杜恕被免为庶人,流放到章武郡,这一年是嘉平元年。杜恕为人洒脱不羁、随性行事,考虑事情却不知防备祸患,最终招致这样的灾祸。
Before he had been in office for a year, the son of a Xianbei chieftain bypassed the frontier passes and rode directly to the province with several dozen horsemen. The provincial authorities executed one of his young attendants without submitting a memorial to the throne. Cheng Xi thereupon impeached Du Shu, who was handed over to the Commandant of Justice and sentenced to death. Because his father Du Ji had drowned in devoted service to the state, Du Shu was pardoned, reduced to commoner status, and exiled to Zhangwu Commandery. This was in the first year of Jiaping. Du Shu was free-spirited and unconcerned with conventions, but he did not know how to guard against trouble, and ultimately brought this disaster upon himself.
《杜氏新书》曰:喜欲恕折节谢己,讽司马宋权示之以微意。恕荅权书曰:「况示委曲。夫法天下事,以善意相待,无不致快也;以不善意相待,无不致嫌隙也。而议者言,凡人天性皆不善,不当待以善意,更堕其调中。仆得此辈,随欲归蹈沧海乘桴耳,不能自谐在其间也。然以年五十二,不见废弃,颇遭明达君子亮其本心;若不见亮,使人刳心著地,正与数斤肉相似,何足有所明,故终不自解说。
The New Book of Du Clan states: Cheng Xi wanted Du Shu to humble himself deferentially and apologise, and prompted Major Song Quan to convey his wishes discreetly. Du Shu replied to Song Quan in a letter: "What of the subtle intentions that lay beneath the surface? In dealing with the affairs of the world, goodwill always brings satisfaction, while ill will invariably breeds resentment. Some critics say that human nature is wholly bad, and that one should not treat others with goodwill, lest one fall prey to their schemes. If I had to live among such men, I would rather take to the blue sea on a raft, for I could never accommodate myself to them. Yet at fifty-two I have not been cast aside, and have often met discerning gentlemen who understood my true intentions. If no one understood me, even cutting out my heart and laying it on the ground would reveal no more than several Jin of flesh. What could that prove? I have therefore never sought to explain myself.
程征北功名宿著,在仆前甚多,有人出征北乎!若令下官事无大小,咨而后行,则非上司弹绳之意;若咨而不从,又非上下相顺之宜。故推一心,任一意,直而行之耳。杀胡之事,天下谓之是邪,是仆谐也;呼为非邪,仆自受之,无所怨咎。程征北明之亦善,不明之亦善,诸君子自共为其心耳,不在仆言也。」喜于是遂深文劾恕。
The General Who Conquers the North Cheng Xi has long enjoyed distinguished merit and renown, far surpassing my own. Who could surpass the General? If I, as his subordinate, were required to consult him before acting in every matter, great or small, that would not accord with his duty as a superior to impeach wrongdoing. If I consulted him but did not follow his direction, that too would disrupt the harmony between us. I therefore follow my own convictions, rely on my own judgement, and act forthrightly. As for the killing of the Hu, if the people of the realm judge that I acted rightly, then I accomplished the deed; if they say that I acted wrongly, I shall bear the consequences myself and blame no one else. It matters little whether Cheng, General Who Conquers the North, understands the matter or not. The various gentlemen will judge it for themselves; it does not depend on anything I might say." Cheng Xi thereupon drew up a harsh indictment against Du Shu.
《杜氏新书》曰:喜欲恕折节谢己,讽司马宋权示之以微意。恕荅权书曰:「况示委曲。夫法天下事,以善意相待,无不致快也;以不善意相待,无不致嫌隙也。而议者言,凡人天性皆不善,不当待以善意,更堕其调中。仆得此辈,随欲归蹈沧海乘桴耳,不能自谐在其间也。然以年五十二,不见废弃,颇遭明达君子亮其本心;若不见亮,使人刳心著地,正与数斤肉相似,何足有所明,故终不自解说。
《杜氏新书》记载:程喜想让杜恕屈身向自己道歉,就暗示司马宋权向杜恕委婉表达这个意思。杜恕给宋权回信说:“何必如此委婉曲折?处理天下的事务,以善意相待,没有不带来愉快的;以不善意相待,没有不产生嫌隙的。我遇到这样的人,就想隐退到沧海,坐木筏漂流罢了,无法与他们和谐相处。然而我五十二岁了,还没有被弃置不用,也遇到了不少明达的君子,理解我的本心。如果我的本心不能被理解,就算我把自己的心剖出来放在地上,它也正像几斤肉一样,又怎么能说明什么呢,所以我始终不自我辩解。
程征北功名宿著,在仆前甚多,有人出征北乎!若令下官事无大小,咨而后行,则非上司弹绳之意;若咨而不从,又非上下相顺之宜。故推一心,任一意,直而行之耳。杀胡之事,天下谓之是邪,是仆谐也;呼为非邪,仆自受之,无所怨咎。程征北明之亦善,不明之亦善,诸君子自共为其心耳,不在仆言也。」喜于是遂深文劾恕。
程征北的功名一向显著,比我高出很多,还有人能超过征北将军吗?如果让我处理事务,无论事情大小。凡事都先向上司咨询而后再行动,那就不符合上司督察的本意了;如果咨询了却不遵从上司的意见,又不符合上下顺畅相处的道理,所以我就秉持着自己的本心,按照自己的意愿,直接去做事罢了。诛杀胡人这件事,天下人认为它是对的,那就是我做成的。若说这是错的,那我自己承担后果,没有任何怨恨和责怪。程征北能理解我也很好,不能理解我也很好,诸位君子各凭本心行事就行了,不在于我的话。程喜于是就罗织罪名弹劾恕。
初,恕从赵郡还,陈留阮武亦从清河太守征,俱自薄廷尉。谓恕曰:「相观才性可以由公道而持之不厉,器能可以处大官而求之不顺,才学可以述古今而志之不一,此所谓有其才而无其用。今向闲暇,可试潜思,成一家言。」在章武,遂著体论八节。又著兴性论一篇,盖兴于为己也。四年,卒于徙所。
当初,杜恕从赵郡回来,陈留人阮武也从清河太守任上被征召,两人都到了廷尉那里接受审问。阮武对杜恕说:“我看,您的才性可以遵循公道,但守持得不够严格;器能可以身居高位,但谋求起来却不顺遂;才学可以记述古今,但志向不够专一。这就是所谓有那样的才能却没有发挥那样的作用。如今即将有空闲,可以试着潜心思考,写成一家之言。”杜恕在章武时,便撰写了《体论》八节,又写了《兴性论》一篇,大概是为自身修养而发的。四年,在流放地去世。
Previously, when Du Shu returned from Zhao, Ruan Wu of Chenliu was likewise recalled from his post as Grand Administrator of Qinghe. Both appeared before the Commandant of Justice. Ruan Wu said to Du Shu, "As I see it, you have the talent and character to follow the Way, yet lack firmness in upholding it; you have the capacity to hold high office, yet your path to advancement is beset with obstacles; and you have the learning to expound past and present, yet lack singleness of purpose. This is what is meant by possessing talent without putting it to use. Now that you have leisure, devote yourself to quiet reflection and set forth a teaching of your own." While at Zhangwu, Du Shu accordingly wrote the Discourse on Fundamentals in eight sections, and another essay entitled Discourse on Arousing the Nature. Both likely sprang from his commitment to self-cultivation. In the fourth year, he died in exile.
《杜氏新书》曰:以为人伦之大纲,莫重于君臣;立身之基本,莫大于言行;安上理民,莫精于政法;胜残去杀,莫善于用兵。夫礼也者,万物之体也,万物皆得其体,无有不善,故谓之体论。
The Du Shi Xinshu / New Book of Du Clan states: Du Shu held that of the cardinal bonds of human society, none was weightier than that between ruler and subject; of the foundations of personal conduct, none was greater than speech and action; for securing the ruler and governing the people, nothing surpassed institutions and laws; and for subduing cruelty and putting an end to killing, nothing was better than the art of war. Ritual gives form to all things, and when all things attain their proper form, all are brought to goodness. Hence he called the work the Discourse on Form.
《杜氏新书》曰:以为人伦之大纲,莫重于君臣;立身之基本,莫大于言行;安上理民,莫精于政法;胜残去杀,莫善于用兵。夫礼也者,万物之体也,万物皆得其体,无有不善,故谓之体论。
《杜氏新书》集中:杜恕认为人伦的大纲,没有比君臣关系更重要的;安身立命的根本,没有比言行更重要的。安定君主、治理百姓,没有比政法更精深的;遏制残暴、消除杀戮,没有比用兵更有效的。礼,是万物的根本准则。万物都遵循了礼这个根本,就不会有不好的地方,所以把这本书命名为《体论》。
甘露二年,河东乐详年九十余,上书讼畿之遗绩,朝廷感焉。诏封恕子预为丰乐亭侯,邑百户。恕奏议论駮皆可观,掇其切世大事著于篇。
甘露二年,河东人乐详已九十多岁,上书申诉杜畿遗留下来的功绩,朝廷为此感动,下诏封杜恕的儿子杜预为丰乐亭侯,食邑一百户。杜恕的奏议、论驳等文章都值得一看,选取其中切合当时大事的,著录在本传中。
In the second year of Ganlu, Yue Xiang of Hedong, then over ninety, submitted a memorial recounting Du Ji's lasting achievements. The court was moved and decreed that Du Shu's son Du Yu be enfeoffed as Neighbourhood Marquis of Fengle, with a fief of one hundred households. Du Shu's memorials, proposals, arguments, and rebuttals are all worthy of attention. Those bearing most directly on the great affairs of his age are recorded here.
《魏略》曰:乐详字文载。少好学,建安初,详闻公车司马令南郡谢该善左氏传,乃从南阳步诣该,问疑难诸要,今左氏乐氏问七十二事,详所撰也。所问既了而归乡里,时杜畿为太守,亦甚好学,署详文学祭酒,使教后进,于是河东学业大兴。
The Weilüe / Brief History of Wei states: Yue Xiang, courtesy name Wenzai, was fond of learning from an early age. At the beginning of the Jian'an era, he heard that Xie Gai of Nan Commandery, Director of Official Carriages at Sima Gate, was well versed in the Zuo Tradition. He therefore travelled on foot from Nanyang to visit him and seek answers to doubts and difficulties. The extant Master Yue's Seventy-Two Questions on the Zuo Tradition was written by Xiang. Once his questions had been resolved, he returned home. At the time, Du Ji was Grand Administrator of Hedong. He too was deeply devoted to learning and appointed Yue Xiang Literary Section Libationer, entrusting him with the instruction of younger scholars. Thereafter, learning flourished greatly in Hedong.
至黄初中,征拜博士。于时太学初立,有博士十余人,学多褊狭,又不熟悉,略不亲教,备员而已。惟详五业并授,其或难教,质而不解,详无愠色,以杖画地,牵譬引类,至忘寝食,以是独擅名于远近。详学既精悉,又善推步三五,别受诏与太史典定律历。太和中,转拜骑都尉。详学优能少,故历三世,竟不出为宰守。至正始中,以年老罢归于舍,本国宗族归之,门徒数千人。
During the Huangchu era, Yue Xiang was summoned and appointed an Erudite. The Imperial Academy had only recently been established, with only ten or so Erudites. Most were narrow in their learning and lacked mastery of their subjects. They seldom taught in person and merely filled their posts. Yue Xiang alone taught all five classics. When some pupils proved difficult to teach and still failed to understand after repeated questioning, Yue Xiang showed no anger. Drawing diagrams on the ground with his staff, he used analogies and comparable examples to explain the matter, often forgetting sleep and food. Thus he alone won renown far and wide. Yue Xiang possessed both profound and comprehensive learning and was also skilled in calendrical calculation. By a separate edict, he was ordered to work with the Grand Astrologer in establishing the standard calendar. During the Taihe era, he was transferred to Commandant of Cavalry. Though eminent in scholarship, Xiang lacked administrative abilities. Consequently, through three reigns, he was never sent out to serve as governor or Grand Administrator. During the Zhengshi era, Yue Xiang retired on account of old age and returned home. He was highly esteemed by the clans of his native commandery, and his disciples numbered several thousand.
《魏略》曰:乐详字文载。少好学,建安初,详闻公车司马令南郡谢该善左氏传,乃从南阳步诣该,问疑难诸要,今左氏乐氏问七十二事,详所撰也。所问既了而归乡里,时杜畿为太守,亦甚好学,署详文学祭酒,使教后进,于是河东学业大兴。
《魏略》记载:乐详,字文载,年少时就喜爱学习。建安初年,乐详听说公车司马令、南郡人谢该擅长讲解《左氏传》,就从南阳步行前往拜访他,询问诸多疑难要点。如今《左氏乐氏问》中的七十二件事,是乐详所撰写的。当所问的问题都已经弄清楚后,他就回到了家乡。当时杜畿担任太守,也非常好学,任命乐详为文学祭酒,让他教导后辈学生。于是河东的学术事业十分兴盛起来。
至黄初中,征拜博士。于时太学初立,有博士十余人,学多褊狭,又不熟悉,略不亲教,备员而已。惟详五业并授,其或难教,质而不解,详无愠色,以杖画地,牵譬引类,至忘寝食,以是独擅名于远近。详学既精悉,又善推步三五,别受诏与太史典定律历。太和中,转拜骑都尉。详学优能少,故历三世,竟不出为宰守。至正始中,以年老罢归于舍,本国宗族归之,门徒数千人。
到了黄初年间,朝廷征召乐详并任命他为博士。当时太学刚刚设立,有十多位博士,学问大多浅陋狭窄,又不熟悉教学,几乎不亲自授课,只是充数罢了。只有乐详同时教授五经。有的问题很难理解,向他询问也还是不明白,乐详也没有生气的神色,用手杖在地上比划,旁征博引、类比举例,甚至到了废寝忘食的地步,因此他独远近闻名。乐详的学问精深全面,又擅长推算天文历法,朝廷另外下诏让他和太史一起制定历法。太和年间,他转任骑都尉。详学识优秀但能力不足,因此历经三代,最终没有出任地方长官。到正始年间,因为年老退休回家。他本乡的宗族都归附他,门徒有数千人。
《杜氏新书》曰:恕弟理,字务仲。少而机察精要,畿奇之,故名之曰理。年二十一而卒。弟宽,字务叔。清虚玄静,敏而好古。以名臣门户,少长京师,而笃志博学,绝于世务,其意欲探赜索隐,由此显名,当涂之士多交焉。举孝廉,除郎中。年四十二而卒。经传之义,多所论駮,皆草创未就,惟删集礼记及春秋左氏传解,今存于世。
The Du Shi Xinshu / New Book of Du Clan states: Du Shu's younger brother Du Li, courtesy name Wuzhong, was keenly perceptive from an early age and had a fine grasp of essentials. Du Ji thought him remarkable and therefore named him Li. He died aged twenty-one. Du Shu's younger brother Kuan, courtesy name Wushu, was pure and detached, profound and tranquil, quick-witted and fond of antiquity. Born into the family of an eminent minister, he grew up in the capital. Yet he devoted himself to broad learning and withdrew entirely from worldly affairs, intent on probing the abstruse and uncovering the hidden. He thereby gained renown, and many men in positions of influence befriended him. He was nominated as a Filial and Incorrupt and appointed Gentleman of the Household. He died aged forty-two. Du Kuan produced many critical discussions of the meanings of the Classics and their commentaries, but all remained unfinished drafts. Only his edited compilation of the Record of Rites and his explanations of Zuo's Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals survive today.
《杜氏新书》曰:恕弟理,字务仲。少而机察精要,畿奇之,故名之曰理。年二十一而卒。弟宽,字务叔。清虚玄静,敏而好古。以名臣门户,少长京师,而笃志博学,绝于世务,其意欲探赜索隐,由此显名,当涂之士多交焉。举孝廉,除郎中。年四十二而卒。经传之义,多所论駮,皆草创未就,惟删集礼记及春秋左氏传解,今存于世。
《杜氏新书》记载:杜恕的弟弟杜理,字务仲,年少时就机敏明察、能抓住关键要点,杜畿认为他很奇特,所以给他取名为理。他二十一岁就去世了。另一个弟弟杜宽,字务叔,淡泊宁静,聪明而喜好古代文化事物。因为出身于名臣之家,从小在京城长大,却志向坚定,学识渊博,不参与世俗的事务,只想要探究幽深隐微的道理,因此他名声显著,当权的人大多和他交往。他被推举为孝廉,被任命为郎中,四十二岁时去世。他对于经传的义理,有很多自己的论述和辩驳,但都只是初稿没有完成,只有删集的《礼记》和《春秋左氏传解》,如今流传于世。
预字元凯,司马宣王女壻。王隐晋书称预智谋渊博,明于理乱,常称「德者非所以企及,立功立言,所庶几也」。大观群典,谓公羊、谷梁,诡辨之言。又非先儒说左氏未究丘明意,而横以二传乱之。乃错综微言,著春秋左氏经传集解,又参考众家,谓之释例,又作盟会图、春秋长历,备成一家之学,至老乃成。尚书郎挚虞甚重之,曰:「左丘明本为春秋作传,而左传遂自孤行;释例本为传设,而所发明何但左传,故亦孤行。」
Du Yu, courtesy name Yuankai, was the son-in-law of Sima Yi. Wang Yin's Book of Jin records that Du Yu possessed profound intelligence and strategic insight, and clearly understood the principles of good government. Du Yu often said, "To establish virtue lies beyond the reach of men like me; but to establish merit and leave words behind are things that ordinary men may accomplish." After surveying the classical canon, he deemed the Gongyang and Guliang traditions as merely specious arguments. He also criticised earlier scholars for failing to grasp Zuo Qiuming's intent and arbitrarily confusing his work with those two traditions. Weaving together the text's subtle meanings, he composed the Collected Explanations of the Classic and Commentary of Master Zuo on the Spring and Autumn Annals. He also consulted the works of many scholars to produce the Explication of Precedents, as well as the Charts of Covenants and Assemblies and the Long Chronology of the Spring and Autumn Annals. Together these formed a complete school of scholarship, but he did not finish them until old age. Zhi Yu, an Imperial Secretariat Court Gentleman, esteemed his works highly, saying: "Zuo Qiuming originally wrote his commentary for the Spring and Autumn Annals, yet the Zuo Commentary came to circulate independently. The Explication of Precedents was originally written for that commentary, but what it illuminates is by no means confined to the Zuo Commentary. It too should therefore circulate independently."
预有大功名于晋室,位至征南大将军,开府,封当阳侯,食邑八千户。子锡,字世嘏,尚书左丞。
Du Yu rendered distinguished service to the house of Jin. He rose to become Grand General Who Conquers the South, received the privilege to Open Office, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Dangyang, with a fief of eight thousand households. His son Du Xi, courtesy name Shigu, served as Imperial Secretariat Left Assistant.
预字元凯,司马宣王女壻。王隐晋书称预智谋渊博,明于理乱,常称「德者非所以企及,立功立言,所庶几也」。大观群典,谓公羊、谷梁,诡辨之言。又非先儒说左氏未究丘明意,而横以二传乱之。乃错综微言,著春秋左氏经传集解,又参考众家,谓之释例,又作盟会图、春秋长历,备成一家之学,至老乃成。尚书郎挚虞甚重之,曰:「左丘明本为春秋作传,而左传遂自孤行;释例本为传设,而所发明何但左传,故亦孤行。」
杜预字元凯,是司马宣王的女婿。王隐的《晋书》称杜预智谋渊博,明白治乱之道,他常说:“道德方面,不是自己所能达到的,建立功业、著书立说,或许自己还能做到。”杜预广泛阅览各种典籍,认为《公羊传》《谷梁传》是诡辩的言论,也不符合先代儒家的学说。前人对《左传》的注释没有探究到左丘明的本意,还随意用《公羊传》《谷梁传》的内容混淆《左传》,于是杜预梳理《左传》中的精深微妙的言辞,撰写了《春秋左氏经传集解》,又参考了其他各家学说,把它称为《释例》。又创作了《盟会图》《春秋长历》,完备地形成了自成一家的学说,到年老时才完成。尚书郎挚虞非常看重他的这些著作,说:“左丘明本来是为《春秋》作传,而《左传》于是独自流传。《释例》本来是为《左传》而作,但它所阐发的道理,又岂止是《左传》,所以它也能独立流传。”
The Jin Zhugong Zan / Appraisal of Officials of Jin states: "Du Gu possessed both ability and breadth of mind." Du Yu's elder cousin Du Wu, courtesy name Shijiang, was likewise talented and highly regarded. He served as Gentleman within the Yellow Gates, but was unjustly executed by Sima Lun, Prince of Zhao. Du Gu's son Du Yi, courtesy name Hongzhi, won a fine reputation in his youth. He served as Assistant to the Grand Administrator of Danyang, but died young. Ruan Wu was also a man of unfettered spirit and great talent. According to the Genealogy of the Ruan Clan, his father Ruan Chen, courtesy name Shixin, declined every summons and recruitment. He compiled the Illustrations of the Three Rites, which circulated throughout the realm.
The Du Shi Xinshu / New Book of Du Clan states: Ruan Wu, courtesy name Wenye, was broad-minded and widely learned, and a man of profound refinement. He rose no higher than Grand Administrator of Qinghe. His younger brother Ruan Bing, courtesy name Shuwen, served as Intendant of Henan. Ruan Bing devoted himself to medicine and compiled a volume of prescriptions. Ruan Bing's son Ruan Tan, courtesy name Hongshu, served under the Jin as Junior Tutor of the Crown Prince and General Who Subdues the East. Ruan Tan's younger brother Ruan Ke had the courtesy name Shidu.
荀绰《兖州记》曰:坦出绍伯父,亡,次兄当袭爵,父爱柯,言名传之,遂承封。时幼小,不能让,及长悔恨,遂幅巾而居,后虽出身,未尝释也。性纯笃闲雅,好礼无违,存心经诰,博学洽闻。选为濮阳王文学,迁领军长史,丧官。王衍时为领军,哭之甚恸。
The Records of Yan province (Xun Chuo) states: Ruan Tan had been adopted to continue the line of their paternal uncle. When their uncle died, he should have inherited the title. Their father, however, favoured Ruan Ke and claimed that Ruan Tan had named him as his heir, so Ruan Ke succeeded to the fief. Ruan Tan was too young to object at the time, but deeply regretted it when he came of age. Thereafter, he wore a plain cloth cap and, even after entering official service, never removed it. Sincere, steadfast, serene, and refined by nature, Ruan Tan observed the rites without fail. He devoted himself to the canonical texts and was widely learned and well informed. He was selected as Scholar to the Prince of Puyang, then promoted to Chief Clerk to the Commander of the Central Army. He died in office. Wang Yan, then Commander of the Central Army, wept for him in profound grief.