Book of Wei, Chapter 17 · Appraisal
On Zhang Liao, Yue Jin, Yu Jin, Zhang He, Xu Huang
評曰:太祖建茲武功,而時之良將,五子為先。
Chen Shou appraises: Cao Cao achieved such brilliant military accomplishments, and among the able generals of the time, these five stood foremost.
于禁最號毅重,然弗克其終。
Yu Jin was especially renowned for firmness and solemnity, yet he failed to maintain these qualities to the end.
Zhang He was celebrated for his resourcefulness and adaptability, while Yue Jin was famed for his valour and decisiveness. Yet when one examines the deeds recorded of them, they do not seem to fully match their reputations.
Perhaps some details of their lives were missing from the records, which were therefore not as full and detailed as those of Zhang Liao and Xu Huang.