Chapters

Book of Wei, Chapter 16 · Biography of Su Ze

Location: opens map on new pageOfficial position: opens official table on new page

蘇則字文師,扶風武功人也。少以學行聞,舉孝廉茂才,辟公府,皆不就。起家為酒泉太守,轉安定、武都,所在有威名。

Su Ze, courtesy name Wenshi, was from Wugong, Fufeng. As a young man, he was renowned for his learning and conduct. He was nominated as Filial and Incorrupt and as a Flourishing Talent, and was recruited to serve in the Excellencies' offices, but declined every appointment. He began his official career as Grand Administrator of Jiuquan, then was transferred successively to Anding and Wudu. Wherever he held office, he commanded awe and respect.

《魏書》曰:則剛直疾惡,常慕汲黯之為人。

The Book of Wei states: Su Ze was resolute and upright, and abhorred evil. He often admired Ji An's character.

《魏略》曰:則世為著姓,興平中,三輔亂,饑窮,避難北地。客安定,依富室師亮。亮待遇不足,則慨然歎曰:「天下會安,當不乆爾,必還為此郡守,折庸輩士也。」後與馮翊吉茂等隱於郡南太白山中,以書籍自娛。及為安定太守,而師亮等皆欲逃走。則聞之,豫使人解語,以禮報之。

The Weilüe / Brief History of Wei states: Su Ze came from a family prominent for generations. During the Xingping era, the Three Capital Regions descended into chaos and famine, and he fled to Beidi. While sojourning in Anding, he sought refuge with a wealthy man named Shi Liang, who did not treat him as well as he had expected. Su Ze sighed indignantly, "Peace will soon be restored throughout the realm. I shall surely return as Grand Administrator of this commandery and humble such mediocrities." He later withdrew with Ji Mao of Pingyi and others to Mount Taibai, south of the commandery, where they took delight in their books. When Su Ze became Grand Administrator of Anding, Shi Liang and the others all sought to flee. Hearing of this, Su Ze sent a messenger to reassure them and treated them with courtesy.

太祖征張魯,過其郡,見則恱之,使為軍導。魯破,則綏安下辯諸氐,通河西道,徙為金城太守。是時喪亂之後,吏民流散饑窮,戶口損耗,則撫循之甚謹。外招懷羌胡,得其牛羊,以養貧老。與民分糧而食,旬月之閒,流民皆歸,得數千家。乃明為禁令,有干犯者輒戮,其從教者必賞。親自教民耕種,其歲大豐收,由是歸附者日多。

When Cao Cao (posthumously honoured as Taizu, the Grand Progenitor) campaigned against Zhang Lu, he passed through Su Ze's commandery. Cao Cao was pleased upon meeting Su Ze, appointing him as guide to the army. After Zhang Lu was defeated, Su Ze pacified the Di tribes of Xiabian and re-established the route West of the River. He was then relocated to serve as Grand Administrator of Jincheng. In the aftermath of war and disorder, officials and commoners had scattered, famine and destitution were rife, and the population had sharply declined. Su Ze tended the people with great care. He won over the Qiang and Hu peoples, obtaining cattle and sheep from them to support the poor and elderly. He also shared grain with the people, and within a month the displaced had all returned, amounting to several thousand households. Su Ze then clearly proclaimed laws and prohibitions. Those who violated them were summarily executed, while those who obeyed were invariably rewarded. He personally taught the people to till and sow, and that year the harvest was abundant. From then on, those who came to submit grew by the day.

李越以隴西反,則率羌胡圍越,越即請服。太祖崩,西平麴演叛,稱護羌校尉。則勒兵討之。演恐,乞降。文帝以其功,加則護羌校尉,賜爵關內侯。後演復結旁郡為亂,張掖張進執太守杜通,酒泉黃華不受太守辛機,進、華皆自稱太守以應之。又武威三種胡並寇鈔,道路斷絕。武威太守毌丘興告急於則。

When Li Yue rebelled in Longxi, Su Ze led the Qiang and Hu in laying siege to him, and Li Yue promptly sought to submit. After Cao Cao's death, Qu Yan of Xiping rebelled and proclaimed himself Colonel Protecting the Qiang. Su Ze mustered his troops and marched against him. Fearing defeat, Qu Yan begged to surrender. In recognition of Ze's achievement, Cao Pi (posthumously honoured as Emperor Wen, the Civil Emperor) appointed him Colonel Protecting the Qiang and enfeoffed him as Marquis Within the Pass. Later, Qu Yan again joined with neighbouring commanderies in rebellion. Zhang Jin seized Du Tong, Grand Administrator of his native Zhangye, while Huang Hua refused to acknowledge Xin Ji, Grand Administrator of his native Jiuquan. Zhang Jin and Huang Hua each proclaimed himself Grand Administrator and rallied to Qu Yan. Three Hu tribes from Wuwei also began raiding and plundering, severing the roads. Guanqiu Xing, Grand Administrator of Wuwei, sent an urgent appeal to Su Ze.

《魏名臣奏》載文帝令問雍州刺史張旣曰:「試守金城太守蘇則,旣有綏民平夷之功,聞又出軍西定湟中,為河西作聲勢,吾甚嘉之。則之功効,為可加爵邑未邪?封爵重事,故以問卿。密白意,且勿宣露也。」旣荅曰:「金城郡,昔為韓遂所見屠剥,死喪流亡,或竄戎狄,或陷寇亂,戶不滿五百。則到官,內撫彫殘,外鳩離散,今見戶千餘。又梁燒雜種羌,昔與遂同惡,遂斃之後,越出障塞。則前後招懷,歸就郡者三千餘落,皆卹以威恩,為官效用。西平麴演等唱造邪謀,則尋出軍,臨其項領,演則歸命送質,破絕賊糧。則旣有卹民之效,又能和戎狄,盡忠效節。遭遇聖明,有功必錄。若則加爵邑,誠足以勸忠臣,勵風俗也。」

The Memorials of Renowned Ministers of Wei records: Cao Pi issued an order asking Zhang Ji, Inspector of Yong Province: "Su Ze, probationary Grand Administrator of Jincheng, has already earned merit by pacifying the people and subduing the Yi. I hear that he has also led troops west to pacify Huangzhong, thereby bolstering our position West of the River. I greatly commend him. Do Su Ze's achievements warrant an increase in noble rank and fief? The conferral of titles is a weighty matter, so I ask your opinion. Report your views in confidence, and do not disclose them for the present." Zhang Ji replied: "Jincheng Commandery was once slaughtered and despoiled by Han Sui. Its people were killed or driven into exile. Some fled to the Rong and Di, while others were engulfed by rebellion and disorder. Fewer than five hundred households remained. When Su Ze took office, he comforted the ravaged survivors within the commandery and gathered in those scattered beyond it. There are now more than a thousand registered households. Moreover, the Qiang tribes of Liangshao had formerly joined Han Sui in wrongdoing and, after his death, fled beyond the frontier barriers. Su Ze repeatedly summoned and conciliated them, and more than three thousand tribes returned to settle in the commandery. He governed them all with authority and benevolence, and they rendered service to the state. When Qu Yan of Xiping and others hatched a treacherous plot, Su Ze promptly sent out troops and bore down upon them. Qu Yan submitted and sent hostages, while Su Ze destroyed and cut off the rebels' supplies. Su Ze not only relieved the people, but also brought harmony to the Rong and Di, displaying the utmost loyalty and integrity. Under an enlightened sovereign, merit is certain to be recognised. To increase Su Ze's noble rank and fief would indeed encourage loyal ministers and improve the customs of the age."

時雍、涼諸豪皆驅略羌胡以從進等,郡人咸以為進不可當。又將軍郝昭、魏平先是各屯守金城,亦受詔不得西度。則乃見郡中大吏及昭等與羌豪帥謀曰:「今賊雖盛,然皆新合,或有脅從,未必同心;因釁擊之,善惡必離,離而歸我,我增而彼損矣。旣獲益衆之實,且有倍氣之勢,率以進討,破之必矣。若待大軍,曠日持乆,善人無歸,必合於惡,善惡旣合,勢難卒離。雖有詔命,違而合權,專之可也。」

At the time, the powerful clans of Yong Province and Liang Province were all seizing Qiang and Hu tribesmen and compelling them to join Zhang Jin and his followers. The people of the commandery believed Zhang Jin could not be withstood. Furthermore, the generals Hao Zhao and Wei Ping had previously been stationed separately at Jincheng and were also ordered not to cross westwards. Su Ze therefore met with the commandery's senior officials, Hao Zhao and the others, and the Qiang chieftains, and said: "Though the rebels are now strong, they have only recently banded together. Some were coerced into joining them, and they are unlikely to be of one mind. If we exploit an opening and attack, the good and the wicked will surely part. The good will then come over to us, swelling our numbers while diminishing theirs. With our forces enlarged and our spirit doubled, we can lead them against the rebels and are certain to prevail. But if we wait for the main army, the conflict will be prolonged. With nowhere else to turn, the good will inevitably join the wicked. Once they have joined together, it will be difficult to separate them swiftly. Though acting now would contravene the imperial command, it is justified by expediency. We should therefore act on our own authority."

於是昭等從之,乃發兵救武威,降其三種胡,與興擊進於張掖。演聞之,將步騎三千迎則,辭來助軍,而實欲為變。則誘與相見,因斬之,出以徇軍,其黨皆散走。則遂與諸軍圍張掖,破之,斬進及其支黨,衆皆降。演軍敗,華懼,出所執乞降,河西平。乃還金城。進封都亭侯,邑三百戶。

Hao Zhao and the others agreed. They then raised troops to relieve Wuwei, secured the surrender of the three Hu tribes, and joined Guanqiu Xing in attacking Zhang Jin at Zhangye. Hearing of this, Qu Yan led three thousand infantry and cavalry to meet Su Ze, claiming that he had come to reinforce the army, though he in fact intended treachery. Su Ze lured him to a meeting, beheaded him, and displayed his head before the troops. Qu Yan's followers scattered and fled. Su Ze and the other forces then besieged Zhangye and took it, executing Zhang Jin and his supporters. The rest of the rebels all surrendered. With Qu Yan's army defeated, Huang Hua took fright, released his captives, and begged to surrender. The lands West of the River were thus pacified, and Su Ze returned to Jincheng. He was advanced to Capital Neighbourhood Marquis, with a fief of three hundred households.

徵拜侍中,與董昭同寮。昭嘗枕則膝卧,則推下之,曰:「蘇則之膝,非佞人之枕也。」初,則及臨菑侯植聞魏氏代漢,皆發服悲哭,文帝聞植如此,而不聞則也。帝在洛陽,嘗從容言曰:「吾應天而禪,而聞有哭者,何也?」則謂為見問,鬚髯悉張,欲正論以對。侍中傅巽掐則曰:「不謂卿也。」於是乃止。

Thereafter, Su Ze was summoned and appointed Palace Attendant, serving alongside Dong Zhao. Dong Zhao once laid his head on Su Ze's knees. Su Ze pushed him off, saying, "Su Ze's knees are no pillow for a sycophant." When Su Ze and Marquis of Linzi, Cao Zhi, first heard that Wei had supplanted the Han, both donned mourning dress and wept bitterly. Cao Pi heard of Cao Zhi's conduct, but not Su Ze's. Once, while in Luoyang, the emperor casually remarked, "I accepted the abdication in accordance with Heaven, yet I hear that someone wept. Why was that?" Su Ze thought the question was addressed to him. His beard bristled, and he was about to answer with a forthright remonstrance when the Palace Attendant Fu Xun pinched him and said, "His Majesty was not referring to you." Su Ze then desisted.

《魏略》曰:舊儀,侍中親省起居,故俗謂之執虎子。始則同郡吉茂者,是時仕甫歷縣令,遷為宂散。茂見則,嘲之曰:「仕進不止執虎子。」則笑曰:「我誠不能效汝蹇蹇驅鹿車馳也。」初,則在金城,聞漢帝禪位,以為崩也,乃發喪;後聞其在,自以不審,意頗默然。臨菑侯植自傷失先帝意,亦怨激而哭。其後文帝出游,追恨臨菑,顧謂左右曰:「人心不同,當我登大位之時,天下有哭者。」時從臣知帝此言,有為而發也,而則以為為己,欲下馬謝。侍中傅巽目之,乃悟。

The Weilüe / Brief History of Wei states: Under the conventional rites system, the Palace Attendant personally attended to the emperor's daily needs, and was therefore commonly referred to as "the chamber-pot bearer". At first, Ji Mao, a man of Sun Ze's home commandery, had only just served as a County Magistrate before being reassigned to a supernumerary post. On seeing Sun Ze, Ji Mao mocked him: "Your advancement in office has brought you no further than bearing a chamber pot." Su Ze laughed and replied, "I truly cannot emulate you, riding leisurely about in a deer cart." Earlier, while in Jincheng, Su Ze had heard that the Han emperor abdicated the throne and mistakenly believed that he had died, so he went into mourning. When he later learnt that the emperor was still alive, he reproached himself for not having ascertained the truth and became markedly subdued. The Marquis of Linzi, Cao Zhi, grieved that he had lost Cao Cao's favour, had also wept in bitter anguish. Later, while Cao Pi was out on an excursion, he recalled Cao Zhi with resentment and turned to his attendants, saying, "Men's hearts differ. When I ascended the throne, there were those in the empire who wept." The accompanying ministers understood that the emperor's remark was directed at someone in particular. Su Ze thought it referred to him and was about to dismount and apologise. The Palace Attendant Fu Xun signalled to Su Ze with his eyes, and only then did Su Ze understand that the remark was not directed at him.

孫盛曰:夫士不事其所非,不非其所事,趣舍出處,而豈徒哉!則旣策名新朝,委質異代,而方懷二心生忿,欲奮爽言,豈大雅君子去就之分哉?詩云:「士也罔極,二三其德。」士之二三,猶喪妃偶,況人臣乎?

Sun Sheng remarked: A gentleman does not serve one he condemns, nor condemn one he serves. His decisions to give or withdraw his allegiance, to take office or retire, are surely not made lightly. Yet having entered his name on the rolls of a new court and pledged his service to another dynasty, he still harboured divided loyalties, grew resentful, and sought to vent his feelings through outspoken criticism. Is this truly the principle a noble gentleman should uphold when choosing whether to remain or withdraw? The Odes states, "You know no constancy; fickle is your conduct". A man's fickleness may cost him his spouse; how much more so for a minister?

文帝問則曰:「前破酒泉、張掖,西域通使,燉煌獻徑寸大珠,可復求市益得不?」則對曰:「若陛下化洽中國,德流沙漠,即不求自至;求而得之,不足貴也。」帝嘿然。後則從行獵,槎桎拔,失鹿,帝大怒,踞胡牀拔刀,悉收督吏,將斬之。則稽首曰:「臣聞古之聖王不以禽獸害人,今陛下方隆唐堯之化,而以獵戲多殺羣吏,愚臣以為不可。敢以死請!」帝曰:「卿,直臣也。」遂皆赦之。然以此見憚。

Cao Pi asked Su Ze, "When we conquered Jiuquan and Zhangye, envoys began travelling to and from the Western Regions, and Dunhuang presented a pearl one cun across. Could more be obtained by purchase?" Su Ze replied, "If Your Majesty's transforming influence pervades the realm and your virtue reaches even the deserts, such pearls will come of themselves without being sought. If they must be sought out and purchased, they are not worth prizing." The emperor fell silent. Later, Su Ze accompanied him on a hunt. A stake in the hunting enclosure came loose, allowing a deer to escape. The emperor was furious. Seated on a stool, he drew his sword and ordered all the officers overseeing the hunt arrested for execution. Su Ze knelt and bowed his head to the ground, saying, "I, your servant, have heard that the sage kings of old never harmed men for the sake of beasts. Your Majesty now seeks to exalt the civilising rule of Yao, yet would put numerous officials to death over a hunt. Your foolish servant believes this cannot be allowed. I dare plead for their lives on pain of death." The emperor said, "Sir, you are an upright minister," and pardoned them all. Yet thereafter, the emperor grew wary of Su Ze.

黃初四年,左遷東平相。未至,道病薨,謚曰剛侯。子怡嗣。怡薨,無子,弟愉襲封。愉,咸熈中為尚書。

In the fourth year of Huangchu, Su Ze was demoted to Principality Chancellor of Dongping State. Before reaching his post, he fell ill and died en route. He was posthumously titled Marquis Gang, the Resolute Marquis. His son Su Yi succeeded him. Su Yi died without a son, so his younger brother Su Yu inherited the fief. During the Xianxi era, Su Yu served as an Imperial Secretariat.

愉字休豫,歷位太常光祿大夫,見晉百官名。山濤啟事稱愉忠篤有智意。臣松之案愉子紹,字世嗣,為吳王師。石崇妻,紹之女兄也。紹有詩在金谷集。紹弟慎,左衞將軍。

Su Yu, courtesy name Xiuyu, successively served as Minister of Ceremonies and Household Counsellor, and is listed in the Official Posts of Jin. In Shan Tao's The Explanation of Matters, Shan Tao praised him as loyal and steadfast, with sound judgement. Your servant Songzi notes that Su Yu's son Su Shao, courtesy name Shisi, served as tutor to the Prince of Wu. Shi Chong's wife was Su Shao's elder sister. Su Shao's poems are in the Jingu Collection. Su Shao's younger brother, Su Shen, was General of the Central Guards on the Left.